Tread climber or elliptical?

on 9/15/2009 by sexybeast | filed in: Exercise

So I've been working out for a little over half a year now, and it's been going pretty good. I've definately gotten a lot stronger. I've been doing pretty good about watching what I eat too. The only problem is that a couple of months ago I decided to start bulking up a bit because I want to be bigger, not just stronger and healthier. So my body fat percentage keeps getting higher. I'm somewhere around 17 or 18% and climbing. I was trying to jump rope everyday, but I haven't been able to stick with it. So I'm getting ready to buy either a tread climber or an elliptical, but I can't decide which one to get. The tread climber advertises that it burns more calories than a treadmill. The elliptical advertises that it's easier on your joints. Of the two models I can afford, the tread climber costs about $700 more, but it sounds more confident about burning calories. Any opinions?

Best Answer

Resolved
jriles17 jriles17
September 15, 2009
9:24 PM
personally i like the elliptical bc iut is easier on the joints an also has different levels of difficulty....but ive never used a treadclimber so i cnt say anythin for it or against it

Answers Sort By 

digitaldel digitaldel
September 17, 2009
1:59 PM
Elliptical. Just run on it longer to burn more calories.
 Login or Sign Up for Free to Rate
fitnessman2 fitnessman2
September 16, 2009
9:43 PM
Elliptical its a much moe solid workout and it burns more fat than muscle.
 Login or Sign Up for Free to Rate
The Az Beast The Az Beast
September 16, 2009
7:36 PM
I got the chance to try the lower priced treadclimber and peronally its a piece of crap, it felt uncomfortable just did not like it. As for Cardio next to the best Cardio machine ever designed for fat loss and muscle tone The Versa Climber the Elliptical comes in second.
 Login or Sign Up for Free to Rate
The Az Beast The Az Beast
September 16, 2009
7:34 PM
Always the Elliptical, but I guess I did not need to answer this you already have my known opinion lol
 Login or Sign Up for Free to Rate
Peace2u Peace2u
September 16, 2009
5:18 PM
tread climber
 Login or Sign Up for Free to Rate
DareDevil  DareDevil
September 15, 2009
9:27 PM
At your age, motivation and great work ethics I would buy the tread climber and burn more calories, etc. GOOD LUCK !!!!!!!
 Login or Sign Up for Free to Rate
jriles17 jriles17
September 15, 2009
9:24 PM
personally i like the elliptical bc iut is easier on the joints an also has different levels of difficulty....but ive never used a treadclimber so i cnt say anythin for it or against it
 Login or Sign Up for Free to Rate
 
Add to Favorites
Message sexybeast
 
Similar Unresolved Fitness Questions
No Fit Q's to display.
 
Similar Resolved Fitness Questions