ProAna sites: Health Support with Bizarre Twist

on 3/24/2008
ProAna sites: Health Support with Bizarre Twist Despite researching health and fitness thoroughly, when a girl mentioned that I should try to pull some girls away from proana sites and get them to join FitConnect. “They need some serious help, they’d probably like FitConnect.” Serious help? What are you talking about?

“They’re support sites for weight loss, you should advertise on them”

Well that makes sense, we’re always trying to get more weight loss oriented individuals to our site, but I was confused why she first made it seem almost like a rescue operation. She told me to just google it and I’ll find out.

So after googling for a few minutes I soon realized that Pro-Ana is slang for Pro-Anorexia – the sites are forums and blogs where anorexics (mostly female) post extreme weight loss tips, moral (or, immoral) support, and write rants of frustration. Commonly I came across message boards stating “I gained 5 lbs back and I hate myself.”

I also found many proanas that claimed, “I barely ate anything all week and I’m down 5 lbs.” And along with posts like this, the girls would post their mood as being happy. Then reading on I would find posts from the same girls at a later date stating, “I binge ate a lot today and I’ve gained 10 lbs this week”. No surprise - the mood here was quite unhappy.

So what now for our little friend who just put on 10 lbs and probably thinks she looks like a whale? She’ll probably double her non-eating efforts this week and cut her typical dinner of 2 rice cakes down to merely 1 rice cake. And half way through she might get an extra burst of motivation (from her friends on proana sites) and throw the 2nd half of her rice cake in the trash.

Doesn’t sound very healthy does it? Well, it’s not. Binge dieting – and the proana sites that support it, are not healthy and are very controversial. There are many people and organizations that are trying to get these sites shut down because of their immoral nature. Some have been successfully shut down - Although I’m not sure how, since in America we have freedom of speech. Actually, I think that died off somewhere considering I’ve once been arrested for referring to a female-enemy of mine as horse-face.

But anyway, I think the people who run these sites should be educated on how unhealthy anorexia is and they should decide to take them down themselves. And these boney proanas should clue in on what a good looking body is.

If you’re someone who is having trouble with your body image and may have an eating disorder, I recommend checking out WomensDietAndFitness.com and TheFitnessBlackbook.com – two sites that know what a healthy, good looking body is, and give quality advice on how to achieve it.

http://womensdietandfitness.com – Authored by FitConnect member, FitnessGrl, who is relatively new to FitConnect, but shoots up in the rankings due to her very informative advice.

http://thefitnessblackbook.com - Authored by FitConnect member, Rusty, who is one of the top bloggers in our community, and I often refer to his content because he mixes fact with personality.

Would I recommend either of these sites for bodybuilders? No. In fact, you’ll most likely be offended by Rusty’s strong position on looking “Hollywood” not monstrous. And following FitnessGrl’s advice won’t produce the next Ronnie Coleman, but she could probably take you from a 20 jean size to an 8. But definitely, if you’re looking to slim down the right way – these are two great sites to follow.


Ryan Mayberry - FitConnect.comRyan Mayberry

http://fitconnect.com/ryan


Tags  wacky finds, health watch
 Login or Sign Up for Free to Rate


Comments
You must be logged in to post a comment. Login or Sign Up for Free

JimB JimB
March 28, 2008
8:25 PM
It's really scary to know that there are sites like that out there. That's almost as bad as a site advocating smoking! I sure hope we can convert some of these girls to a healthier method of weight control.

fitnessgrl fitnessgrl
March 25, 2008
8:07 PM
I cannot believe their are sites like that out there! Ridiculous! I see so many people at the gym who think they look so 'hot' when in fact they are SICK looking and its so hard not to tell them that! (I'm too nice!)

Thanks for the comment on my blog! And Thanks to you too Rusty...You are the best!

plucky plucky
March 24, 2008
9:10 PM
Nice photo choice for this article - a before (hot!) and after (not!). Really drives home the point of how twisted is this perspective on what "healthy" looks like.

MleighS84 MleighS84
March 24, 2008
3:20 PM
what a great blog - it really makes you sit back and think about how obsessive our society is about weight - and i like your style in retrospect to how many would write the blog - you referenced a possible solution and gave props to 2 amazing and helpful blogs, most merely state the problem and thats it - kudos to you!!!

 
ryan ryan March 24, 2008  3:55 PM
Thanks Miranda - i think our society's problem is that people don't just sit back and think enough. If these girls took a minute to really think "do i look good as a skeleton" and "am I any happier now that I starve myself?" I think the societal problem would fix itself.

 
Rusty Rusty March 25, 2008  2:36 AM
I have never heard of these types of sites...that is crazy stuff. Not sexy at all! Thanks for the plug about my blog...I do poke fun of bodybuilders at times, but believe it or not...I'm friends with a few of the top bodybuilding bloggers. We poke fun at each other but in a friendly way. I'm friends with Angie (FitnessGrl), her blog is very good...she puts a lot of work into it for sure. Go over there and comment to keep her busy!

ryan
 
Add to Favorites
It's OK To Brag
Sync Settings
Message ryan
View Profile
 
Stats
Rank 42/2787
Comments 6
Views 1168
Brags 0
Ratings 0
Avg Rating 0
 
Tag Cloud
 
Categories